OMG! thank you soo much for making a 2nd one! PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE make it a DVD as well! i live no where near NY, London, or Shanghai.

P.S. Emmy Rosum should be CHristine and Gerard Butler should be the phantom! That’d rock!

how about lee mead? ? ? ?

it would be brill if gerard butler would be the phantom again.

A sequel, brilliant, but as Megan says, PLEASE! PLEASE! PLEASE! make it a DVD as well, because I also don’t live anywhere near NY, London or Shanghai, and yes Emmy Rossum should be Christine and Gerard Butler should be the Phantom as it wouldn’t be the same if those two roles were played by someone different

OMG!!!!!!!!! IM 9 AND I LOVE THIS MOVIE AND I OWN EVERY THING AND IVE WACHED 30 TIMES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I LOVE GERARD BUTLER

Of course it wouldnt be the same if those two didn’t do it...it would be much better. If you have only seen the movie and not the play, you should definitely see it on Broadway because although Emmy Rossum and Gerard Butler did a wonderful job in the movie, theyre no where near the level of the performers who are in the Broadway cast at any given moment. They simply do not possess the vocal capabilities or stage presence required for a play as large scale as Phantom. And the movie and the play are two entirely different things, so if a play is out they will not simply record it onto a dvd.

please make the new phantom of the oper 2 in two a movie with gerard butler as the phantom.  he played a wonderful phantom and i love the movie and the broadway show

im really excited about doing a second phantom, the first one was such a big hit and when i heard that andrew loyd webber was thinking about doing a sequal i was over the moon.
The same cast will be there and i have read the script and it looks fantastic. It should be coming out on dvd round about easter in, 2009
thank you to every one who supported us in the first making xx

I am really excited about the new phantom of the opera.I did actually audition for the lead of christie but Emmy got the role instead which i think she deserved sooo much more than me and apart from that she can actually sing i do not think i would be very good in a musical anyway, im much better at being in things like Pirates of the Caribbean with Orlando Bloom and Johny Depp, Which by the way there will be a 4th upcoming Pirates movie in July 2009 with Russel Brand who is a brilliant actor.
xx

ALW made TPOM, and yet I have heard nothing of it. It’s 2009, Sir Webber, and we Phans are eager to see, hear, read, watch, breathe, eat, sleep your next masterpiece!

Megan, you suck, because gerard and emmy are not actors or singers. they suck indescribably.

Emmy’s small, almost non-existant whiny voice wouldn’t carry past the edge of the stage.

gerard doesn’t even sing, nor can he pronounce english words normally.

ex- gerard butler: “EYEEEE AM YEUUURR ENGIL”

michael crawford: “I AM YOUR ANGEL!

how retarded is that? hes ugly as shit and hes fat and old too. i can’t imagine HOW he got cast as Erik in the damn movie.

the person who should play the phantom in the second movie should be Gerard Butler he was so good in the first one and it would be weard if he wasnt. i think i would want to wach it more if he was the phantom.you should also keep the origanal cast from the last one so it looks and sounds the same but please dont get rid of Gerard he is yumalishis and my heart would die if you didnt my mom would probly die to she is a huge fan like me DONT GET RID OF GERARD BUTLER HE IS MY LOVE

THIS IS NOT A MOVIE, YOU SILLY GIRL.

I repeat, NOT a movie.

Original Phans for the win.
I do have to admit I do love Gerard’s accent.

-Bonfire

if you were all real fans of Phantom of the Opera you would all know that there is a carry on book called Phantom in Manhatten,
but only if you were a true fan would you know that.
if a sequel was to happen itd be great, but to be honest, P.I.M doesn’t exactly have the greatest foundations for film nor show

@Jodie: PIM is probably not worth reading, but I might try it anyways. I say ALW should do something with Susan Kay’s Phantom. Now THAT was good.

Yes Emmy Rossum and Gerard Butler did a good job in the movie, but that was the movie! Has anyone seen a live production, local or big time, of the Phantom? A Broadway production of anything, imo, is way better then anything Hollywood could produce. Not to say the movie was bad, I enjoyed it, but when compared to Broadway...well there is no comparison.

I don’t know whether to be extremely excited or extremely afraid.
I trust Andrew Lloyd Webber, but...sequels. They’re never as good as the original. And, in this instance, you know that everyone is going to be comparing it to POTO, there’s no way you couldn’t. There will be so much hype surrounding this musical, I just hope it doesn’t fall short haha
With that said, I can’t wait to find out who the cast is and (hopefully sooner than later)hear the music!
@ Bonfire: ALW & Susan Kay’s Phantom is my dream musical! lol
If anyone hasn’t read that book and calls themself a phantom ‘phan’, I am so disappointed ^_~

@ “Megan is stupid”
You indeed, are an odd individual.
Haven’t you heard? The setting of the whole story is on Paris, France. What did you expect? That there would not be any accent? Stop being childish and grow up for goodness sake. Gerard Butler is a fine actor and singer. I can’t compare him with Michael Crawford’s amazing singing, but cut him some slack will you? Of course the movie is going to differ greatly than the musical. Emmy Rossum does not have a whiny voice, what are you talking about? She’s seems fine to me for a girl who filmed such an amazing movie at the age of sixteen. So shut it.

If Phantom of the Opera 2 is going to become a movie - I’d be happy to see Emmy Rossum and Gerard Butler return to those roles; but if it is set to be onstage, I’d love to see Sarah and Michael. I live in Brooklyn’s Coney Island, so if they do film it there, I might be able to catch a glimpse on the actors. If not, we’ll have to wait and see when it comes out. I hope this sequel won’t be a let-down. I’d be heartbroken to see such a good movie being destroyed, but seeing what Andrew Lloyd Webber did with the first movie, I’m sure he’ll do well.

Oh please no. Gerard Butler was horrible. (No offense)
Truthfully, those who think Gerard Butler was “AMAZING” has obviously not seen the real musical.

I mean Michael Crawford and Sarah Brightman would be great to have back as Christine and the Phantom.. but aren’t they a little old to play the roles?

Michael Ball HAS to play the Phantom in London.  No one else will do!

Good afternoon. Don’t ever take a fence down until you know the reason it was put up. Help me! I find sites on the topic: Nail infection lamisil. I found only this - Lamisil cream price. The clotrimazole lately I switched to lamisil, as it a once a day application the lamisil and clotrimazole are quite safe. Whose taper than vainly buy terbinafine gel his generosity effects of nicotine unseen she they did pepcid crazy meds resounding shores terbinafine lupus resign. Thanks in advance. Tory from Djibouti.

I’m going camping tomorrow and my sister asked “What are you more exited about, phantom of the opera, or camping” and im a freak and i said phantom of the opera! I LOVE it and i have the cd and the movie! I’M ONLY 10!!!

Please keep all the actors/actresses the same from the phantom of the opera movie. I’d be depressed for life if others took their places. I am in love w phantom of the opera. Thank you!!!!